Can Solar Power Replace a Standby Generator?

Published: February 27, 2025 | By Mark Jenkins, Renewable Energy Specialist

As power outages become more frequent due to extreme weather and aging infrastructure, homeowners are increasingly looking for reliable backup power solutions. While standby generators have traditionally been the go-to option, advances in solar technology and battery storage systems have many wondering: can solar power effectively replace a standby generator?

This question has become especially relevant with the emergence of integrated solar systems like the Tesla Solar Roof, battery solutions like the Powerwall, and even portable power stations like those from Jackery. But the answer isn't simply yes or no—it depends on your specific needs, location, budget, and expectations.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll compare solar power systems with traditional generators, explore the capabilities of today's leading solar solutions, and help you determine which backup power approach might be right for your home.

Quick Answer

Solar power with battery storage can replace a standby generator for many homes, but with important limitations. Solar works best for those who experience frequent but shorter outages, have sufficient roof space, live in sunny regions, and can accept higher upfront costs for lower long-term operating expenses. Traditional generators remain superior for extended outages (3+ days), homes with high power demands, and situations requiring immediate backup with no sunlight dependency.

Solar Power vs. Standby Generators: Head-to-Head Comparison

Factor	Solar + Battery Systems	Standby Generators
Initial Cost	Higher ($15,000-$50,000+)	Lower ($5,000-$15,000)
Runtime During Outages	Limited by battery capacity and solar production	Unlimited as long as fuel is available
Operating Costs	Very low (sunlight is free)	Ongoing fuel and maintenance costs
Environmental Impact	Minimal carbon footprint	Produces emissions, noise pollution
Daily Benefits	Reduces electric bills year-round	Only provides value during outages
Power Capacity	Typically lower (<20kW) unless extensively sized	Higher capacity options available (up to 48kW)
Weather Dependency	Depends on sunlight for recharging batteries	Functions regardless of weather conditions
Maintenance Requirements	Minimal (occasional panel cleaning, battery checks)	Regular (oil changes, filter replacements, etc.)
Lifespan	25+ years for panels, 10-15 years for batteries	15-20 years typical
Tax Incentives	Significant federal and state incentives	Limited or none

Cost Analysis Key Takeaways

Solar + battery systems have higher upfront costs but can offer significant long-term savings.
Standby generators have a lower initial cost but incur ongoing fuel and maintenance expenses.
Hybrid solutions can provide a balance between cost and reliability.
The breakeven point for solar vs. generator is typically around years 7-10.

The Best of Both Worlds: Hybrid Approaches

For many homeowners, the ideal solution isn't choosing between solar and a generator—it’s combining them. A hybrid approach might involve using a solar + battery system as your primary backup and a small generator to cover extended outages or periods of low sunlight.

Solar + Battery Primary System

Handles 90% of outage scenarios
Provides daily energy savings
Low environmental impact
Keeps essential circuits running

Small Backup Generator

Activates during extended outages
Can recharge batteries when solar production is insufficient
Lower capacity, more cost-effective unit

Sizing Your Solar Battery Backup System

If you’re considering a solar backup, proper sizing is critical. Battery storage systems must be designed based on your home's critical loads and the desired days of autonomy.

Step 1: Determine Critical Loads

Refrigeration, lighting, essential electronics
Medical equipment, if applicable
Basic HVAC or heating needs (if required)

Most homes have critical loads totaling between 10-25 kWh per day.

Step 2: Calculate Battery Capacity

Use the formula: Daily critical load (kWh) × Desired days of autonomy = Required battery capacity.

Example: 15 kWh/day × 2 days = 30 kWh battery capacity needed.

2 Tesla Powerwalls = 27 kWh (close approximation)
3 Enphase IQ Batteries = 30 kWh
2 LG RESU16H Prime = 32 kWh

Tesla Solar Roof vs. Traditional Solar Panels

Tesla's Solar Roof integrates solar cells into roofing materials for a seamless look, while traditional panels are mounted on your existing roof. For backup power, both systems rely on battery storage (like the Tesla Powerwall) to provide electricity during outages.

Feature	Tesla Solar Roof	Traditional Solar Panels
Aesthetics	Integrated, nearly invisible	Visible mounting on roof
Cost	$35,000-$75,000+ (with roof replacement)	$15,000-$35,000 (panels only)
Efficiency	Lower per square foot	Higher per square foot
Installation Time	5-14 days (full roof replacement)	1-3 days typically
Backup Capability	Depends on Powerwall capacity	Depends on Powerwall capacity

Portable Solar Generators: The Jackery Solution

Portable solar generators like those from Jackery offer flexibility and affordability for powering essential devices during an outage, though they cannot replace whole-home backup systems.

Jackery Solar Generator Systems

Jackery's portable power stations paired with SolarSaga panels provide emergency backup for small loads.

Popular Models:

Explorer 1000 Pro: 1,002Wh, ~$1,099
Explorer 1500 Pro: 1,512Wh, ~$1,699
Explorer 2000 Pro: 2,160Wh, ~$2,299
Explorer 3000 Pro: 3,024Wh, ~$2,999

Prices typically include both the power station and solar panels in package deals.

What Can Jackery Power?

Jackery units can charge smartphones, run laptops, power a mini-fridge, and even support a CPAP machine during short outages.

Explorer 1000 Pro: Ideal for basic needs
Explorer 2000 Pro: Supports small appliances like a microwave
Explorer 3000 Pro: Can run larger loads for extended periods

Recharge times with a 400W solar input:

Explorer 1000 Pro: ~2.5 hours
Explorer 2000 Pro: ~5.5 hours
Explorer 3000 Pro: ~7.5 hours

Important: Jackery and similar portable solutions cannot replace a whole-home generator. They are best for powering essential devices and serve as a supplemental backup in a comprehensive system.

Decision Guide: What's Right for Your Home?

To determine which backup power approach suits your needs, consider these key factors:

If You...	Consider This Solution
Want to reduce electric bills while gaining backup power	Solar panels + battery storage
Need a new roof anyway	Tesla Solar Roof + Powerwalls
Experience frequent but short outages	Solar + battery solution
Live in an area with extended outages	Standby generator or hybrid solution
Have high constant power needs	Standby generator
Value environmental impact and quiet operation	Solar + battery solution
Need only essential electronics powered	Portable solution (e.g., Jackery)

Final Thoughts: The Future of Home Backup Power

Solar power with battery storage is increasingly viable as a replacement for traditional generators, especially in sunny regions and for homes with moderate power demands. However, for extended outages or high power needs, a standby generator— or even a hybrid approach—may still be the better option.

The optimal solution often depends on your specific circumstances, including your roof space, budget, outage history, and environmental priorities. By weighing the pros and cons and using tools like our Generator Sizing Calculator, you can make a confident decision on the best backup power solution for your home.

Remember, no single system is perfect for every situation. The key is to balance initial costs, long-term savings, and reliability to suit your lifestyle and needs.

Ready to Explore Your Options?

Connect with qualified professionals who can help design the right backup power solution for your home.

Find a Generator Dealer Generator Sizing Tool